Add Paycheck Post-Tax Deduction: 401(k) ROTH

Currently, the PAYCHECK feature only allows for Pre-Tax 401(k) contribution, and associated Employer Match.

Proposal: Include a Post-Tax 401(k) [ROTH] and associated Employer Match deduction

I have a Roth 401(k) but have to create Custom Post-Tax Deduction entries to correctly reflect this transaction. Roth 401(k) plans have been available for years. Why hasn't Quicken kept up and added this feature to their program?
4 votes

New · Last Updated


  • NotACPA
    NotACPA SuperUser, Windows Beta Beta
    edited March 2020
    I don't understand your request.  Why can't you add your post-tax Roth 401k deduction into the Paycheck Wizard in the same manner as other post-tax deductions?
    Only, in this case, it would be shown as a transfer to the Roth 401k account.
    Q user since DOS version 5
    Now running Quicken Windows Subscription,  Home & Business
    Retired "Certified Information Systems Auditor" & Bank Audit VP
  • qw_u$er
    qw_u$er Member ✭✭
    To answer your question, you simply cannot add a post-tax Roth 401(k) deduction into the Paycheck Wizard in the *same manner* as other post-tax deductions.

    To add a Post-Tax 401(k), it needs to be done as a custom entry using the "Other After-Tax Deduction" feature -- not a problem. The *problem* however is that there is no way to enter the corresponding [Roth] Employer Match as is the case if entering a Pre-Tax 401(k).

    This is precisely my reason for recommending this program enhancement ... the ability to enter a Post-Tax 401(k) and associated Employer match in the *same manner* as other Post-Tax Deductions is not available.

    You have made my point: What you say I should be able to do, the program does not allow.

    Wish I post send screen shots.
  • J_Mike
    J_Mike SuperUser ✭✭✭✭✭
    I have no hands on experience with Roth 401(k) plans but have done some reading and have puzzled over how best to track in Quicken - during both the contribution and distribution phases.

    The employee contributions are made post-tax and grow tax-free.
    Distributions are tax free.

    Th employer matching contributions are pre-tax and growth is tax-deferred.
    Distributions are taxable as ordinary income - sane as a traditional 401(k).

    One article suggested that employers actually maintain two accounts for employees - one account (Roth 401(k)) for the tax free funds and one account (traditional 401(k)) for the tax deferred funds.

    This suggests - should one do the same in Quicken; i.e., maintain two separate accounts???
    Looking ahead - distributions will be a mix of tax-free and taxable income - how managed in QWin>

    Food for thought.
    As to recording the contributions to a Roth 401(k) in QWin;
    I would record the employee contribution as a transfer in the Other After-Tax Deductions.
    I would record the employer match in the Add Pre-Tax Deduction > 401(k)..... dialog (the employee Contribution would be left as $0 in this dialog.. This is he same as an employer match to a traditional 401(k).
    One other change - the Transfers In tax attribute should be cleared for the Roth account - under Account Details.
    QWin & QMac (Deluxe) Subscription
    Quicken user since 1991

  • J_Mike
    J_Mike SuperUser ✭✭✭✭✭
    One more thought on Distrutions from a Roth 401(k) - perhaps the Tax-free and the taxable  distributions are handled completely separate from each other???

    If so, this would support the approach of maintaining two separate accounts in QWin.
    QWin & QMac (Deluxe) Subscription
    Quicken user since 1991

  • qw_u$er
    qw_u$er Member ✭✭
    J_Mike, thanks for the tip. Your response prompted me to do some research and I discovered that I incorrectly presumed the Employee Match would be Roth. They are not. Although I have a Roth 401(k), the Employer Match goes into a Traditional 401(k).

    Employer Matches
    If an employer matches a traditional 401(k) plan contribution, it is standard for it to match one for a Roth 401(k). Unlike the employee's contribution, however, the employer's contribution is placed into a traditional 401(k) plan, and it is taxable upon withdrawal. The employee's contribution goes into a Roth 401(k).

    All this said, although it would be nice for QWin to offer a dedicated Post-Tax 401(k) entry, it is not required...

    For those with a Roth 401(k), when using the Paycheck Wizard, users will have to set up BOTH a Pre- and Post-Tax 401(k). The purpose of the Pre-Tax portion will be used to make the appropriate (Pre-Tax) Employer Match and the Pos-Tax (using the "Other After-Tax Deduction" feature) will be used for the employee's Roth contribution.

    Hope this helps anyone with 401(k) Roths.

    Invest wisely!
  • J_Mike
    J_Mike SuperUser ✭✭✭✭✭
    Thanks for the additional info.

    This confirms that a participant in a Roth 401k plan should set up two separate accounts for tracking in Quicken;
    A Rich 401k account for the employee contributions,
    A traditional 401k account for the employer match.

    Upon reaching retirement, distributions from the two accounts will be completely separate events - each governed by the respective rules for Roth and Traditional accounts.

    Majes sense!!
    QWin & QMac (Deluxe) Subscription
    Quicken user since 1991

  • weiand
    weiand Member
    J_Mike, a follow up question. Once I set up one Roth 401K account for employee contribution and a tradiction 401K account for employer match, what is a good automatic way to manage quicken download from my 401K account transactions from 401K account web site? The web site records all the transactions with one 401k account.
Sign In or Register to comment.