Reconcile not letting me save, only gives option to finish later

System: Windows 10 and Quicken for Windows R.33.24
For both checking account and credit card account, I go though the reconcile steps, get a $0 difference (i.e. fully reconciled) but am not getting the option to "save". The only option I have is to quit or finish later. How to I save so that the transactions get updated with the "R". I am reconciling to the paper statement - online/auto reconcile is turned off.