Thank you for
reaching out on the community and telling us about your issue. Sorry for the late response. I believe recently I saw another user have a similar issues with the reconcile window not adding up the all the transactions properly. The way they fixed the issue was to uncheck and recheck the transactions. In this case try it on the transactions that are showing 250. This should get it to show up instead with 5 transactions for the correct amount.
Please let us know
if this helps resolve the issue for you.