Hello @mikeglaspy
Thank you for reaching out on the community and telling us about your issue. I do apologize for the issue you're having. It sounds like you may have the automatic reconcile enabled.
You can double check by going to the account with the register you're having issues with then going to the reconcile. You should then be presented with the screen asking if you'd like to use paper statement or online balance. Below online balance you'll want to make sure auto reconcile downloaded transactions is not check marked.
Once you get the chance let us know if you're able to get the option off. If not we'll see what we can try next.
Thanks,
Quicken Francisco