Identical transactions but for date entered - one appears in budget, one does not

My paychecks are entered into my register automatically using scheduled income reminders so they are entered EXACTLY the same each time (obviously amounts adjusted as needed, but categories unchanged). My budget is set up for "net salary". I have two paychecks entered for the month of January but only one appears as actual income in my budget report. I have reviewed bothtransactions to ensure they are the same, I have deleted the one that does not show up and re-entered it into my register with no luck. Anyone have any ideas?