Hello @dan.greenberg.ct
Thank you for reaching out on the community and telling us about your issue. I do apologize for the issue you're having. That is quite odd that it does this actually. When you edit the reminder does it show the categorization properly? When you edit and save does it keep the correct details you previously put in?
I believe remaking the reminder may be the best way to to see if we're able to fix it. I would make the new one first and then cross check it with the one you currently use to make it a bit simpler to fill out without having to remember all the exact details. This might be the way we do need to try as it's been an issue for a couple of months so I don't think it's related to any of the recent updates to the program.
Once you have a chance let us know what you're able to find. If you do end up remaking the reminder let us know if you do have issues still as well.
Thanks,
Quicken Francisco