It seems counterintuitive, the "Reconcile using online balance" setting needs to be disabled/unchecked under Account>Edit>Online Services. The next time you reconcile, the account will trigger "use paper or online balance?". You can then re-select the option.
Quicken Phone Support Current Hours of Operation:
Monday through Friday
5:00 am to 5:00 pm PDT
Quicken Chat Support Current Hours of Operation:
Monday through Sunday