Lifetime Planner IDEA: Allow User to Change Account Order of Withdrawal Sequence in LTP

Scooterlam
Scooterlam SuperUser, Windows Beta Beta
Lifetime Planner IDEA:  Allow User to Change Account Order of Withdrawal Sequence



Studying alternative investment account withdrawal strategies in LTP may be useful in exploring more tax-efficient approaches to draw-down.  Changes in withdrawal strategy,  can improve end-of-plan balances and yearly cashflows for overall plan success.   But currently, it is not possible to tell LTP to reorder and prioritize alternative account withdrawal sequences other than a program determined, fixed order.   


This idea allows the user to explore different account withdrawal sequences or strategies in LTP, such as:


1.   A user-customized account withdrawal sequence and timing, or

2.   An "auto" optimization feature to find the "best" account withdrawal sequence, or

3.   A pro-rata strategy where account type withdrawals are done in parallel

additionally, 

4.  Incorporation of Account Specific Use IDEA
.
5.  Incorporation of Roth Conversion IDEA



Please Consider Voting for this IDEA.  Add your comments and thoughts as well.


THE ISSUE


Currently, Quicken LTP fixes the order of account withdrawals during the decumulation stage of the retirement plan.   From my prior look into this, the current LTP order of withdrawal is:


1.   RMDsthen

2.   Taxable Accounts, then

3.  Tax Free Accounts (ex. ROTH), then

4.   Tax Deferred Accounts (ex. IRA, 401K)


There may be some nuances to this ordering, such as once RMDs are started at age 70 (in LTP)...unless the Tax Deferred account is exhausted, LTP will no longer draw from the taxable account despite a cash buildup. This can result in a tax inefficient result.


THE CHANGE


Depending upon the user's account types and balances in their portfolio (and situation) there may be more tax-efficient approaches to account withdrawal order.  But currently, it is not possible to tell LTP to reorder and prioritize account withdrawals other than the default order, described above.  So....


1.   Allow the user to change their order of withdrawals for any permutation of LTP investment accounts types.   Include both sequential and pro-rata withdrawal strategies.   Ensure that RMDs are always taken first to avoid the 50% tax penalty.


2.   In addition to reordering accounts in #1 , add an "auto-optimize" feature to allow Quicken to automatically test all account type permutations for maximum plan ending balance and other user defined criteria (ie.  minimum yearly account balance)


3.  Allow the user to, at any time,  return or reset LTP default order of withdrawals.


4.  Leverage current "What-if" dialog to study order of withdrawal scenarios.  Produce Graph / Tabular results to illustrate benefits of the selected "alternative order of withdrawal" strategy vs. current strategy.  Image 1.


5.   Document in HELP the current default order of withdrawals along with this new feature.


MAKING THIS FEATURE BETTER


In order to better assess the effectiveness of different "order of withdrawal" strategies, IRA, 401k and ROTH account types must have their basic tax characteristics defined/maintained in LTP.   There are several additional IDEA posts on this subject.    Does LTP need to have a "highly precise" tax model for this feature to aid in decision making?  TBD.

Note, this is a pretty common feature in modern professional planning software but also increasingly popular in consumer level planners where tax models for different account types are basic.  Nonetheless, a useful feature to allow a user to balance "conventional practice" against ones own situation.



Please Consider Voting for this IDEA.  Add your comments and thoughts as well.



HELPFUL EDUCATION LINKS:

Fidelity:  Tax-savvy Withdrawals in Retirement

Kitces:  Tax-Efficient Spending Strategies From Retirement Portfolios

Financial Planning Association Study





IMAGE 1  -  "What if" dialog




7
7 votes

New · Last Updated