I have two Discover credit card accounts with the same log in.

HannyDan

Since adding the second account, Quicken is not able to connect to my first account to update transactions. Is there a way to connect two accounts with the same log in? Or am I now destined to manually update these two credit cards in Quicken?

Boatnmaniac

You should be able to connect both accounts with the same login.  I suggest you do the following:

1. Back up your data file.
2. Make note of the Opening Balance dollar amounts.
3. Deactivate both accounts (from Account Details, Online Services tab). 
   
4. Do Setup Now (from the Online Services screen of one account) or via Add Account. 
   
5. When the connection is made you should be prompted by Quicken to make a decision regarding what to do with the downloaded data...be sure to Link them to the accounts you already have set up in Quicken.
6. This process might enter duplicate transactions into your account registers.  If this happens you will need to manually delete the duplicates.
7. Check the accounts balances.  If they are out of balance, check the Opening Balance transactions and correct them if needed (see #2 above).

Both accounts should now be connected for downloading at the same time as each other.