Are Community emails formatted correctly for forwarding?

leishirsute

I have Community emails forwarded from my gmail to Yahoo and Outlook accounts.

Now both Yahoo and Outlook indicate problems with the Community format that do not allow forwarding.

I would think this is a problem on my side but all other forwarding from gmail to yahoo and outlook works without problems. Only Community emails have the problem.

This is the error reported by yahoo to gmail when gmail tries to forward a Community email to Yahoo. Forwarding to outlook generates the same error.

-------- Forwarded Message --------

Subject:	Delivery Status Notification (Failure)
Date:	Wed, 10 Jan 2024 11:32:43 -0800 (PST)
From:	Mail Delivery Subsystem <[Removed - Email]>
To:	reply4u2+caf_=[Removed - Email]

data:image/png;filename=icon.png;base64,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 Message blocked Your message to [Removed - Email] has been blocked. See technical details below for more information. LEARN MORE data:image/png;filename=warning_triangle.png;base64,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 This link will take you to a third-party site

The response from the remote server was: 554 5.7.9 Message not accepted for policy reasons. See https://postmaster.yahooinc.com/error-codes

=======End Forward Message ===================================

This is what error code 554 implies (Source: https://senders.yahooinc.com/smtp-error-codes/ )

What are 5XX (553 and 554) permanent errors?

• A 553 or 554 SMTP error indicates an email could not be delivered due to a
  permanent problem. Message delivery can be permanently deferred
  because:
  • You're trying to send a message to an invalid email address.
  • Your message failed authentication checks against your sending domain's DMARC or DKIM policy.
  • The message contains characteristics that Yahoo won't accept for policy reasons.
  • Other suspicious behavior which leads Yahoo to issue a permanent rejection for your SMTP connection.
  • Your IP is listed by Spamhaus. Please check with .
• If you consistently receive 5xx errors when sending to Yahoo, we encourage you to review our Sender Requirements & Recommendations, since 5xx errors can be a symptom of a more widespread, general problem.
• You should not retry sending an email that comes back with with a 5xx error. List managers
  should have a policy for removing email addresses that generate 5xx
  errors/bounces. https://www.spamhaus.org

smayer97

I cannot speak about Outlook but this is an occasional problem with Yahoo. Yahoo decides what is permissible to be forwarded to it. A few years ago, I ran into a similar problem with Gmail forwarding community emails to Yahoo. I had to stop using Gmail for forwarding these community emails.

I have the same problem with Gmail forwarding emails from another site to Yahoo but in this case, it is only emails generated from one area only but not another. Again, Yahoo controls this.

leishirsute

@smayer97 Outlook also rejects forwarding from gmail for Quicken community emails only.