IRA WithdrwX now shows as deposit, not withdrawal

sd_mark

I'm using Quicken Classic Windows R61.21. I survived the Vanguard meltdown late last month by just waiting it out. Transactions are still downloading and my accounts still have Tracking Method "Complete - Positions and Transactions." But the issue now is NOT about downloaded transactions, but about a recurring "manual" transaction, intended to transfer from an IRA to a non-retirement account.

Last month, I have a negative WithdrwX in the IRA plus a positive XIn in the Nonretirement account, a proper transfer out/in.

This month, I have this recurring transaction:

which entered a positive WithdrwX in the IRA and a negative XOut in the Nonretirement account:

The IRA transaction details look like this:

The nonretirement transaction details look like this:

What happened here? How can a WithdrawX be considered a deposit? How can both sides of a transfer be "Cash Transferred out"?

Thanks for your help.

Quicken Jasmine

Hello @sd_mark,

I understand how concerning it must be to see your recurring manual transaction behaving incorrectly, especially after successfully managing the Vanguard situation.

Since your transactions were entered correctly last month but are now showing unexpected behavior, it’s important to determine what might have changed. Have you recently made any modifications to your account settings, such as switching tracking methods, adjusting tax attributes, or updating transaction categories? Also, did you manually enter this transaction before it was recorded, or did Quicken automatically generate it based on the recurrence settings?

Let me know!