I'm using Quicken Classic Premier version 8.0.1 running on Macintosh running macOS 14.4.1 (Sonoma).
I have quite a few eBillers set up in Quicken, and I'd like to add Toyota Financial Services for a new vehicle that we recently purchased and are financing through Toyota. When trying to establish the connection with TFS in Quicken as I have done for all of my other eBillers, I am prompted for my username and password as expected. I am then prompted to enter a six-digit "verification" code sent to my phone. I enter the code and then see "Logging in…" However, a few moments later I am prompted once again for a verification code. No second code is sent to my phone, and if I enter the code that came the first time, I receive an error message. Proceeding without entering a code is not an option.
Why am I being prompted for a verification code after I've already entered the code that Toyota sent me? Has anyone else been able to successfully connect with Toyota Financial Services? It seems like others must be having success, so why am I having trouble getting through?