What does "Set Account based rule" do?

Mark A
Mark A Quicken Windows Subscription Member

I thought the purpose of an account-based rule was to allow transactions to be assigned to different categories based on a combination of the Payee Name and the Account to which the transaction is being downloaded, but it is not working the way I expected.

Let’s say I have a credit card for my own use, and a debit card for my daughter’s use, and I want to keep track of what I spend in restaurants vs. what she spends in restaurants.

I created a line in the Memorized Payee list for Payee: Wendy’s, Category: Dining, and an account-based rule specifying my credit card; and I set up a second line for Payee: Wendy’s, Category: Daughter:Dining, and an account-based rule specifying her debit card.

When I download a Wendy’s purchase from my credit card, I want it to be categorized as Dining, and when I download a Wendy’s purchase from her debit card, I want it to be categorized as Daughter:Dining, but all Wendy’s purchases are categorized as Daughter:Dining regardless of what account they are downloading to.

What am I missing, or what am I doing wrong?

Why is Quicken giving me the ability to specify an account-based rule if it isn’t sorting transactions based on the rules I set up?

Comments