Show Cash Value instead of Market Value for Investments in the Accounts List on the left

Unknown

Is it possible to show the cash value instead of the market value for investment accounts on the left account lists?  

mshiggins

The amount that shows in the Account Bar is the account balance. It will be either the current balance or the ending balance, depending on which of those balances you have selected to show.



There is currently no way to select cash value or market value. Can you explain a bit about why you want to do that?

NotACPA

What do you mean by "cash value"?  Is that what you paid for the securities contained in the accounts(s)?

Because, normally, I'd think of the "value" of any security/account as being what I can get in cash for that security/account ... AKA the "market value"

Unknown

mshiggins said:

The amount that shows in the Account Bar is the account balance. It will be either the current balance or the ending balance, depending on which of those balances you have selected to show.



There is currently no way to select cash value or market value. Can you explain a bit about why you want to do that?

I'm talking specifically about my 401k investment in the Account Bar.  If I click on the 401k account then I see 2 values displayed.  Cash and Market.  However in the Account bar on the left it just shows the Market value.  I was wondering if there was a setting that will allow me to toggle what value is shown.

Unknown

Cash Value is the term the quicken tool uses.  I have an investment account setup for my 401k and when you click on the account you will see 2 values "Market" and "Cash".  However in the Account Bar on the left it uses the "Market" value.  The cash value is what I would see if I directly logged into my 401k website and is the total contributed.  I'm not sure how quicken gets the market value and I'm not sure I fully trust that number.  I see your point, but since two values exist it would be nice if you can choose the one that you prefer to see.  

mshiggins

I would try to get to the root of why you have a different value for cash and market value for your 401(k).

NotACPA

At the bottom of an investment account register, 3 values are shown:  Securities Value, Cash Balance and Total Market Value. 
What shows in the Account Bar is the "Total Market Value", which is the sum of the Securities Value and the Cash Balance.

SO, where does Q use the term "Cash Value"?  And what is it that you want to see in that Account Bar to the left (or right, depending upon individual settings)?

Unknown

I have the same issue as here.  I have several 401Ks and only in one Company's download (VOYA) it shows the Market value as a different amount than it should be.  I don't see this problem with Vanguard so I think it is a bug in Quicken 2017 for MAC.  It is not taking the right number and applying it as as the Market value.  This is problematic because it shows an incorrect number for my investment summary.  I've called customer service and they were not able to even understand this issue. 

What is happening is that Market value is reflecting the total gain/loss not the market value of the portfolio. 

q_lurker

Marilyn Merrifield said:

I have the same issue as here.  I have several 401Ks and only in one Company's download (VOYA) it shows the Market value as a different amount than it should be.  I don't see this problem with Vanguard so I think it is a bug in Quicken 2017 for MAC.  It is not taking the right number and applying it as as the Market value.  This is problematic because it shows an incorrect number for my investment summary.  I've called customer service and they were not able to even understand this issue. 

What is happening is that Market value is reflecting the total gain/loss not the market value of the portfolio. 

@Marilyn Merrifield:  This is a Windows discussion.  Your tangential question will not get proper exposure here.  You need to find a relevant Mac question, or start your own Mac question.

Unknown

I have the same issue in Windows 10. I set up my 401K account in Quicken. At the bottom of the transactions I have: Securities Value, Cash Balance and Total Market Value. Total Market Value is the sum of the first two. My account actually only has what is show as the Cash Value of this investment. How can I get the total in my account list to show Cash Balance instead of Total Market Value?

q_lurker

Ron Mitnick said:

I have the same issue in Windows 10. I set up my 401K account in Quicken. At the bottom of the transactions I have: Securities Value, Cash Balance and Total Market Value. Total Market Value is the sum of the first two. My account actually only has what is show as the Cash Value of this investment. How can I get the total in my account list to show Cash Balance instead of Total Market Value?

My account actually only has what is show as the Cash Value of this investment. 

Does your real world account have that value as cash or does it have it as securities, possibly including money market securities?  

If your real world account does not have securities value, why does your Quicken representation of that account have securities?  Eliminate the securities from your Quicken account and then your Total Market Value will be $0 + Cash Value and that is what wil appear in the Account bar.

You cannot change Quicken to show something different that total market value in that account bar.

Unknown

Ron Mitnick said:

I have the same issue in Windows 10. I set up my 401K account in Quicken. At the bottom of the transactions I have: Securities Value, Cash Balance and Total Market Value. Total Market Value is the sum of the first two. My account actually only has what is show as the Cash Value of this investment. How can I get the total in my account list to show Cash Balance instead of Total Market Value?

How would I eliminate the securities? This sounds like the perfect solution, but can't find where to do it. There are no specific entries (that I can tell) for securities.

q_lurker

Ron Mitnick said:

I have the same issue in Windows 10. I set up my 401K account in Quicken. At the bottom of the transactions I have: Securities Value, Cash Balance and Total Market Value. Total Market Value is the sum of the first two. My account actually only has what is show as the Cash Value of this investment. How can I get the total in my account list to show Cash Balance instead of Total Market Value?

@Ron Mitnick:  Presumably your Holdings view from your account transaction list would something like



Are you saying that presentation does not list any securities to justify the Security Value number?

Unknown

my cash balance is something like 16K, but on my account bar it shows as $168k. My investments aren't performing that well. Note, when I first added the account, the security value was around $800k. I reconciled to get it down to $168k.

Unknown

Ron Mitnick said:

I have the same issue in Windows 10. I set up my 401K account in Quicken. At the bottom of the transactions I have: Securities Value, Cash Balance and Total Market Value. Total Market Value is the sum of the first two. My account actually only has what is show as the Cash Value of this investment. How can I get the total in my account list to show Cash Balance instead of Total Market Value?

did you ever get an answer for this? I have quicken 2017 and have the same issue. not sure why others are struggling so much to understand the question. on left pane i want to see the cash value(Which is the real value fo my 401k) and not market value - which i have no idea where quicken gets it from - i think the product is buggy

Tom Young

Kevin Gurne said:

Cash Value is the term the quicken tool uses.  I have an investment account setup for my 401k and when you click on the account you will see 2 values "Market" and "Cash".  However in the Account Bar on the left it uses the "Market" value.  The cash value is what I would see if I directly logged into my 401k website and is the total contributed.  I'm not sure how quicken gets the market value and I'm not sure I fully trust that number.  I see your point, but since two values exist it would be nice if you can choose the one that you prefer to see.  

"on left pane i want to see the cash value(Which is the real value fo my 401k) and not market value"

No, the "real value" of your 401(k) absolutely, positively is the amount that you could get if you sold all the securities. 

Broadly speaking, a 401(k) account is no different that a brokerage account; you may have deposited $10,000 into the account but if the securities that you purchased with that $10,000 are now worth $50,000, or now worth $157.67, the market value is all-important.

If you want to see how your investments have done vis-a-vis your deposited amount then you look inside the account to see that.  But if a banker or a mortgage lender asks "what's your net worth?" then that $50,000 or $157.67 really is the relevant figure.

If, somehow, you just have to see what your "cash vale" in the account is, i.e., the value of the account with no unrealized appreciation or depreciation, then simply run an Account Balances or Net Worth report and Customize > Advanced > untick "Include unrealized gains."

Daniel O'Brien

Marilyn Merrifield said:

I have the same issue as here.  I have several 401Ks and only in one Company's download (VOYA) it shows the Market value as a different amount than it should be.  I don't see this problem with Vanguard so I think it is a bug in Quicken 2017 for MAC.  It is not taking the right number and applying it as as the Market value.  This is problematic because it shows an incorrect number for my investment summary.  I've called customer service and they were not able to even understand this issue. 

What is happening is that Market value is reflecting the total gain/loss not the market value of the portfolio. 

Marilyn!  I have had the same issue as you, and I was completely frustrated with customer service ... they had no idea what I was asking for.  I simply want the "cash balance" to appear on my accounts summary on the left hand side of the window.  But instead, the "market value" appears ... which is useless to me, because what I really want to know is how much money I have ... not how much each share is worth.

Unknown

I am having the same issue.  I want my account balance to reflect the "cash value" instead on the market value.  When the market value is shown, it is a much different balance than the cash value.  I would like my balance to show exactly what I have in the account not what I MAY make someday... Anybody have any suggestions??

q_lurker

Jennifer Price Stelzig said:

I am having the same issue.  I want my account balance to reflect the "cash value" instead on the market value.  When the market value is shown, it is a much different balance than the cash value.  I would like my balance to show exactly what I have in the account not what I MAY make someday... Anybody have any suggestions??

Clarification on the expectations is required.  

You put $1000 cash into an investment account. -- (Cash Value = $1000)
You buy 2 securities for $500 each. -- (Cash Value = $0; Securities Value = $1000)
Over time, the value securities changes (as traded on the applicable exchange or reported by the mutual fund family) -- (Cash Value = $0, Securities Value = $1100 or $900 or some other value)
At some point, your securities pay out a cash dividend of $10 -- (Cash Value = $10, Securities Value = $1075 or whatever other value)
and so on ...

What Cash Value are you expecting through these various events?  The $1000 you originally invested?  With the $10 of dividends added on eventually?  (Please don't say $1000.  Cash is Cash; securities are securities.  What you originally invested as cash is no longer cash.)

Market Value is showing what you could have sold the securities for TODAY (or yesterday or last month), not someday in the future.

Please clarify.

Unknown

Jennifer Price Stelzig said:

I am having the same issue.  I want my account balance to reflect the "cash value" instead on the market value.  When the market value is shown, it is a much different balance than the cash value.  I would like my balance to show exactly what I have in the account not what I MAY make someday... Anybody have any suggestions??

You explanation makes sense. Thanks.

Unknown

Jennifer Price Stelzig said:

I am having the same issue.  I want my account balance to reflect the "cash value" instead on the market value.  When the market value is shown, it is a much different balance than the cash value.  I would like my balance to show exactly what I have in the account not what I MAY make someday... Anybody have any suggestions??

To clarify, I will use ficticious numbers - my brokerage account records a market value of $100,000 when actually in my 401K I have $50,000 which makes my account balance seem much bigger than I actually have.  This has only happened when I had to change brokerage firms with my 401K.  I know exactly how much I have in my 401K and it is not the amount shown.

q_lurker

Jennifer Price Stelzig said:

I am having the same issue.  I want my account balance to reflect the "cash value" instead on the market value.  When the market value is shown, it is a much different balance than the cash value.  I would like my balance to show exactly what I have in the account not what I MAY make someday... Anybody have any suggestions??

actually in my 401K I have $50,000

But in what form is the $50K?  I doubt that it is 'Cash'.  

From others questions on this site, I would speculate that in your case, your 401k is holding 'units' of a mutual fund (like a Fidelity Magellan fund) and your Quicken data is set up on shares of that fund.  Shares are not priced the same way that the 401k manager values units, thus you cannot associate the unitized fund to the publicly traded fund that deals in shares.  

NotACPA

Jennifer Price Stelzig said:

I am having the same issue.  I want my account balance to reflect the "cash value" instead on the market value.  When the market value is shown, it is a much different balance than the cash value.  I would like my balance to show exactly what I have in the account not what I MAY make someday... Anybody have any suggestions??

@Jennifer, what does your statement from the 401k show?

And, define "cash value" as you're using the term.  Because, the customary showing in an investment account is the "current account balance" ... i.e., the current value of the securities IN the account ... NOT what has been contributed TO the account.

Tom Young

I've not completely understood the conversation that's going on here.  I'm not sure what, exactly, the term "cash value" means.  So, let's try this:

The attached picture shows the "Holdings" view of a small Account. 

The Account has one security in it and the Holdings window shows both the current value of the security, ("Security Value") and the cost basis of that security. 

The Account has some actual "cash"in it, with the "Market Value" and the "Cost Basis" equal to one another.
 
The value of the security and the cash are added together for "Total Market Value" and it's this number that you typically see in the Account Bar column to the left or right of the Home screen. 

The Holding window also shows the sum of the basis of the security and the cash. 

There's exactly one thing here with the term "cash" attached to it, and that's the cash that's in the Account but has not been used to purchase a security..

On this picture can someone identify, with precison, what the "cash value" is for this Account? 

Unknown

Jennifer Price Stelzig said:

I am having the same issue.  I want my account balance to reflect the "cash value" instead on the market value.  When the market value is shown, it is a much different balance than the cash value.  I would like my balance to show exactly what I have in the account not what I MAY make someday... Anybody have any suggestions??

When I go to the account, I can clearly see "todays balance" which shows the correct amount  in my 401K and "market value" which shows the larger amount. I simply want "todays balance" to show up in my account list... My statement matches the "todays balance."  Not sure where this other number is even from because I don't have that much in the account - wish I did ; )

q_lurker

Jennifer Price Stelzig said:

I am having the same issue.  I want my account balance to reflect the "cash value" instead on the market value.  When the market value is shown, it is a much different balance than the cash value.  I would like my balance to show exactly what I have in the account not what I MAY make someday... Anybody have any suggestions??

@Jennifer:  More info please.  I cannot think of anywhere that Quicken offers something labelled "Today's Balance".  See Tom Young's snipped picture below.  Three values - Security Value, Cash Balance, and Total Market Value - are the commonly presented numbers for any particular day.  

q_lurker

Jennifer Price Stelzig said:

I am having the same issue.  I want my account balance to reflect the "cash value" instead on the market value.  When the market value is shown, it is a much different balance than the cash value.  I would like my balance to show exactly what I have in the account not what I MAY make someday... Anybody have any suggestions??

@Jennifer:  Are you using a Quicken for Mac package?  That is the package that seems to have a Today's Balance field.  If so, this has been a Quicken for Windows discussion and would not be relevant to your situation.

Unknown

I was able to fix this issue by reconciling my account. It asks you what the cash balance is and I put zero.

Unknown

Jim_Harman