Hello @Tony Brocksmith
Thank you for reaching out on the community and telling us about your issue. It sounds as though it's set up to automatically reoncile with the online balance. There's an option for that listed in the account settings. Can you right click on the account -> edit/delete account -> online services In the bottom right you should see a button that says reconcile using online balance.
Once you unchecked this can you go ahead and try to reconcile again. You should be able to select continue without downloading and select either manual or online balance reconcile
Please let us know if this helps resolve the issue for you.
Thanks,
Quicken Francisco