Unacceptable situation with OneDrive and Quicken

13»

Comments

  • Patrick Larkin
    Patrick Larkin Member ✭✭✭

    Back when I had DSL (before getting fiber), it would take more than an hour to "upload" my 200MB qdata to one-drive, or dropbox. Back then, I had a script I used to launch quicken: It would copy my qdata from one drive to a local drive, launch qw.exe on the file and wait. Once I exited quicken, the script would resume by copying the data file back to one drive. This worked OK, but if quicken freezes and requires it to be hard-killed, or if it crashes, forget about trying to use quicken again for at least an hour.

    But face it: we're in the cloud era now. One should not have to remember to pause cloud syncing to operate quicken, and then remember to resume it. Microsoft is pushing onedrive HARD; Quicken needs to recognize this (and stop telling people to put the file in Documents, which M$oft ends up putting in one-drive too)!

  • TraciNarkansas
    TraciNarkansas Quicken Windows Subscription Member

    I've read through the comments and believe I've tried most of them, including copying my QDF to my local drive and opening from there (rather than opening Quicken itself). I have also tried restoring from my backup (also on my local drive). Made attempts to Validate the file as it suggested. None of it has resulted in my being able to get my file to open. The error message always reappears and then says my file is in use. It doesn't help that Quicken Support is only open when I'm at work. :-(

  • RW123
    RW123 Quicken Windows Subscription Member
    edited May 4

    Quicken needs to revert (undo) the changes they made which cause it to break when using OneDrive. You can't tell Window users to stop using OneDrive to backup their most important file.

    Quicken worked fine with OneDrive until their latest update.

  • Ellary Kahan
    Ellary Kahan Quicken Windows Subscription Member ✭✭✭

    It's fine to backup your file to OneDrive. Just don't use the file from OneDrive.

  • ptladasue
    ptladasue Quicken Windows Subscription Member ✭✭

    Thank you for putting all those good suggestions into one response!

  • marcaronson408
    marcaronson408 Quicken Windows Subscription Member ✭✭✭

    A very thoughtful and through response from @Quicken Janean — thank you.

    On the question of our backup service; some of you have wondered whether this warning is timed to promote Quicken's paid backup service. That's an understandable thing to wonder, and I want to be straight with you: the warning exists because we genuinely see data loss cases related to OneDrive conflicts, and we want to help customers avoid them. You do not need our backup service to protect your data. Backing up to OneDrive, a USB drive, or any other location you choose is perfectly effective. The paid backup is an option, not a requirement.

    My feeling is that this paragraph is a well articulated and honest explanation of Quicken's thinking and intent.

    Marc

  • Jim_Harman
    Jim_Harman Quicken Windows Subscription SuperUser ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited May 6

    Thanks for that clear explanation, @Quicken Janean.

    One small change I would recommend: Under Using Quicken across multiple computers, the paragraph starting at Recommended should be one of the bullet points; it is one of the three alternatives.

    Also in Keeping your live file local, you should make it clear that if you choose that option, you must back up the file you used on the second computer and restore that backup when you return to the first computer.

    You might want to consider making just that post an FAQ.

    QWin Premier subscription