It looks like you are sometimes seeing the prices for Compass Inc Class A, which also has the ticker COMP. We have had trouble before when the ticker for an index collides with a company ticker. Try using INDEX:DJA instead, which appears to be Quicken's preferred symbol for that index.
I would call that a bug, the built-in symbol for new files should be INDEX:DJA
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!